Now I have had a soft spot for dystopias ever since I was eleven years old and read The Giver by Lois Lowry. It was My First Dystopia and I was hooked. I count 1984 and Brave New World among my favorite books and I was literally in hysterics when I got ti meet Lois Lowry a few months ago at an award speech in St. Louis. So I wasn't exactly reluctant to read the crop of new teen novels featuring flawed future societies--and, of course, romance. Enter Delerium by Lauren Oliver and Matched by Ally Condie. So how do they compare? Read on to find out.
Matched by Ally CondieThe Story: Cassia lives in a society where every aspect of her life has been decided. The Society decides where its citizens will work, where they will live, who they will marry, and even when they will die . When Cassia is "matched" with her childhood best friend, Xander, Cassia is very pleased. That is, until she falls in love with a very different boy--Ky, an outsider with a secretive and tragic past. This new, forbidden love calls into question everything that Cassia once believed without question and forces her to discover exactly what she is willing to risk for the people she loves.
The Hero: Ky Markham, the aforementioned outsider. He has a dark history with the Society that has left him disenchanted and skeptical. Intelligent and passionate, he understands Cassia in a way that Xander doesn't. He teachers her to write in an age when hand-lettering has been completely forgotten. Together Cassia and Ky hike in the woods and share poetry. Sigh.
The Hero: Ky Markham, the aforementioned outsider. He has a dark history with the Society that has left him disenchanted and skeptical. Intelligent and passionate, he understands Cassia in a way that Xander doesn't. He teachers her to write in an age when hand-lettering has been completely forgotten. Together Cassia and Ky hike in the woods and share poetry. Sigh.
The Society: Everything is regulated. The Officials record everything down to who wins games of checkers. They use everything they learn to remove the "burden" of choice from the lives of the citizens.
Grade: B+

Delerium by Lauren Oliver
The Story: In Lena Haloway's future, love has been cured. At the age of eighteen, every citizen undergoes an operation to prevent the "delirium" (amor deliria nervosa) that accompanies falling in love. But love isn't the only thing that's outlawed--so is good music and "uncureds" interacting with members of the opposite sex. Lena is looking forward to her cure, though, and to the safety it will bring. That is, until three months before she is Cured, when she meets a mysterious and confident boy named Alex who makes her brave and reckless. Suddenly Lena isn't so anxious to be Cured if it means that she will lose Alex.
The Hero: Alex Sheathes, a boy unlike any Lena has every met before. He takes her to forbidden places and reads her long-forgotten poetry (yes, again). What's more, he is courageous, generous, and kind. And the chemistry between these two characters is off the charts.
The Society: It's a bit like the London of 1984 but with an added bonus. Love is a disease that has been completely eradicated. Interactions are restricted and media is closely monitored. What makes it eery is how similar the daily lives of the citizens are to real lives. They jog, they work after-school jobs they hate, they have sleep overs. It feels all too plausible for comfort.
Grade: A
So what's the difference?
These two are so similar that it might be difficult to tell them apart if all you had to go on was a synopsis like this. Both heroines are rule-following white sheep and both heroes are rebels with mysterious pasts who are somehow outside of society. (Aren't they always?) So what's the difference?
Chemistry. The chemistry between Lena and Alex is off the charts. Their romance develops fairly slowly, allowing the reader plenty of time to get to know the characters as individuals and they compliment each other so well. I didn't care as much about Ky and Cassia, though. That may have been because I liked Cassia's intended Match, Xander, better than Ky. In addition, you learn a lot about where Ky has come from but I didn't feel like I actually got to know Ky. He never took shape as a real person for me the way Alex did.
Unputdownability. I listened to Delirium as an audiobook in my car and on more than one occasion I sat in my car to listen even after reaching my destination. I could not stop reading. In fact, this may be one I end up purchasing, despite my limited shelf space. Matched also gets high points in this category, though. I'm a big fan of audiobooks so I listened to this one, too, and I was plugged in to my headphones at every free moment. But my heart didn't race when I was listening to Matched like it did for Delirium.
Conclusion. I found myself thinking about Lena and Alex for days after I finished reading. Their story examines the true meaning of sacrifice. In a word, it was haunting. Want proof? I am by no means an emotional girl. I think I've probably cried twice in the last six months. One of those times was at the ending of Delirium. Researching the interwebs, I find that the sequel, Pandemonium will be out in early 2012. (I'm positively peeing my pants with excitement--I've already pre-ordered my copy!)If I had known that this book was the first in a series when I was reading it, I wouldn't have cried as hard. Okay, yes I would. It's that good. On the other hand, Matched is the first book in a new series. After finishing it, though, I didn't feel rabid for the next installment the way I usually do. I'll read Crossed (the second book) when it comes out this fall but I feel confident that I'll be just fine waiting for it without wetting my pants.











